Disability Book Review: “Lock In” by John Scalzi breaks new ground

The cover to "Lock In"It’s incredibly rare to see characters with disabilities in mainstream fiction. They are a minority group that is routinely overlooked, and even if a book does include a character that has a disability, the character generally falls into one of a few cliches: either their disability is used as a source of inspiration, as the character struggles all book long to “overcome” their disability and succeed despite it, or (and this is quite common in sci-fi and fantasy) their disability is used as a source of magical power or ability. While the first trope is tired and falls into the “inspiration porn” trap, the second one is a cop out that cheapens the impact of having a character with a disability, as the author can easily ignore any actual limitations or challenges that disability would cause. They may not have use of their legs, but who needs legs when you can fly?

Lock In by John Scalzi is one of the first mainstream books that I’ve read that attempts to break free from both of these cliches. Set in the near-future, the premise of the book is that a new disease has swept over the Earth and infected nearly everyone at one point or another. In most people, the disease is akin to a bad case of the flu and they recover, but in a small percentage of the population, it causes “lock in” — a condition where the person is completely paralyzed but their mental faculties remain intact. So over the course of a few years, there are millions upon millions of people that have become locked into their bodies, and the world is forced to adapt to meet the needs of this new segment of the population.

The book’s protagonist is a young man adult* that is locked in, and the plot touches upon so many aspects of life with a disability: the stresses of finding accommodations, starting a new job, dealing with discrimination, living independently, and managing your own healthcare needs. Through the lens of this fictional illness, Scalzi also shines a light on many of the big questions and debates around disabilities, identities, and disability rights that are so relevant today. And he does this while telling a seat-gripping thriller that won’t put you down until the last page.

*Thank you to the comments below for clarifying that the main character’s gender is never specified. Whoops, I’m showing my own biases!

Scalzi’s protagonist is one the best examples I’ve ever read of a character with a disability. They are empowered and strong, and their disability never becomes a crutch, object of sympathy, or plot device. It’s simply a part of who they are, and they have to work with their own limitations and strengths as they unravel the mystery at the heart of the novel. I’m not sure if it was Scalzi’s intention or not, but in Lock In, he has taken a stand against the historical cliches of disabled people and created a character that is fresh, new, and very, very welcome.

For another take on Lock In from a disability perspective, check out David Perry’s review over at The Huffington Post.

Comments (5)

  1. Travis
    Travis
    4 years ago

    Quick note: The main character’s gender is (purposefully) never actually established in the book.

  2. -dsr-
    -dsr-
    4 years ago

    It may also be interesting to you that Scalzi’s protagonist’s gender is never mentioned in the novel.

  3. David Bishop
    David Bishop
    4 years ago

    Good review! Based on some things that Scalzi has said publicly on his blog, not only was that very deliberate, but was very much the point. Something else that’s cool, that’s a lot more subtle (enough so that I completely missed it on my first read through) – Scalzi never actually uses pronouns when referring to the protagonist. That’s one of the reasons why he had both Wil Wheaton and Amber Benson both do readings of the audio book – you can “choose your own gender”, as it were, for the protagonist.

    Anyway, like I said, good review and have a great day.

  4. Steve Slowinski
    Steve Slowinski
    4 years ago

    Thank you both for catching that! It’s funny, I knew that about the main character’s gender identity but forgot to be careful about that myself when writing the post. It’s been updated to reflect that fact. Much appreciated!

  5. David Bishop
    David Bishop
    4 years ago

    Hah! I even refreshed before posting my comment, and I see I was third in line to point out the gender thing. Oh well.

Leave a Comment